Storm in a Teacup – Casting Fuss


April 25, 2016 by bck1402

I made a comment on Facebook regarding the casting of Scarlett Johansson as “The Major” in the upcoming Hollywood adaptation of “Ghost in The Shell”. Simply stated, “I understand the casting move, and I’m not against it”

I thought it was clear, but I was asked to elaborate; more as a counterpoint to the ruckus that seems to have permeated through the ‘net, particularly the complaints of ‘whitewashing’ or ‘cultural/ethnic casting’.

Still, tackling that statement is a two-fold approach, as both halves of that sentence reflects two different aspects regarding the casting. The casting move is, of course, purely a financial issue.


The Business Aspect and Name Recognition

The movie making industry isn’t just there to make the movies; their primary aim is to make money with the movies they produce. This should be of no surprise to even the casual viewer. The constant reports of a movie’s success based on its opening day box-office takings determine the relative failure or success of any given movie these days. This is aside from whether the movie is truly good or bad. The studios bank wholly on name recognition on that end, relying more on the knee-jerk reaction of the average movie-goers rather than those who would consider a movie on its true merits.

Over a decade ago, you could bank on movies starring the likes of Stallone, Schwarzenegger, Ford or Gibson. Then came Denzel, Cruise, and for a while, Reeves. Even when their star power began to wane, their names on a marquee would still pull in the fans and guarantee a certain return on investment by the studios. Of course, times change and now we might be looking at the likes Hemsworth, Downey Jr., Pratt… and do you notice a pattern?

Part of that name recognition is often in casting rather than those behind the screens. If it’s not the stars and their visages gracing the flickering image, then the name might belong to the director. Directors such as Spielberg or Cameron may be able to get their projects going without a big name attached, simply based on their past successes. Consider that the majority of the lead cast in Avatar were mostly lesser-known stars at the time of release and the biggest star Cameron had in that, at the time, would have been Sigourney Weaver. Try naming the stars of Spielberg’s upcoming The BFG, and where you might know them from.

Casting Against The Norm

Getting a ‘name’ cast to a project may give it credence, get it financed and moved into production. It is cases like these why you end up with what is regarded as ‘whitewash’ casting. The sensitivity to this is a more recent development. Moses-RamesesIt is not likely that such complaints were never raised when Charlton Heston and Yul Brynner played Moses and Rameses respectively in The Ten Commandments, nary a complaint about Val Kilmer and Ralph Feinnes essaying the same roles in the animated Prince of Egypt, but the vitriol spewed when Christian Bale and Joel Edgerton played the same characters in the more recent Exodus: Gods and Kings. Were there complaints when Elizabeth Taylor played Cleopatra in 1963, or will there be complaints when Angelina Jolie reprises the role in her upcoming adaptation? Obviously, none of these stars were or are Egyptian.

Speaking of Egypt, there sure were those complaints of the mostly white Australian cast in Gods of Egypt, even though that “Egypt” was a highly fictional and fantastical representation where the Gods and humans lived side by side on some floating disc in outer space! Egyptian born director Alex Proyas had to make a public apology for the casting, even though he’s based in Australia, filmed the movie in Australia, and used Australian stars.

Would having a more ethnically appropriate cast guarantee success of such a movie?

Rinko Kikuchi, Tadanobu Asano, Hiroyuki Sanada, Keanu Reeves, Kou Shibasaki

Rinko Kikuchi, Tadanobu Asano, Hiroyuki Sanada, Keanu Reeves, Kou Shibasaki

Well, let’s look at 47 Ronin. Aside from having Keanu Reeves in the prime spot of lead actor, the rest of the cast were appropriately Japanese. They even worked in a backstory as to why their lead character was not of Japanese origins, justifying the casting of Reeves, but the complaints still flew about and the movie was considered a major flop, barely breaking even given its budget. If ethnic casting was such a major issue, then Australian Hugh Jackman would have been highly inappropriate to play Canadian X-Man, Wolverine. Probably should have tried Canadian star, Ryan Reynolds. And while there are detractors over any American actor taking on the role of James Bond, would there be complaints about Brits Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland taking on the role of all-American teen, Peter Parker, aka Spider-Man?

Incidentally, where James Bond is concerned, the Brits who played the spy are Roger Moore. Timothy Dalton (Welsh by birth), and Daniel Craig. Connery is Scottish, Lazenby is Australian, and Brosnan is Irish

Casting Ghost in The Shell

lucySo, casting Scarlett Johansson is, where the studios are concerned, a financial issue. Given the nature of the movie, the need for a bigger budget would require a star with a certain box-office draw. Johansson has that, thanks to appearances from The Island to Iron Man II to the Avengers movies as well as headlining Lucy. Being the lead star in Lucy was likely crucial to her casting in Ghost in The Shell. That movie banked on her, as she was the lead star and it was an action-packed role. More importantly, the movie was a financial success, which suggested drawing a sizeable audience or returns.

So, yes, they could go with any other Japanese actress who has been making waves on the international movie scene. Rinko Kikuchi has appeared in 47 Ronin, Pacific Rim and The Brothers Bloom, and had the lead in Kumiko, the Treasure Hunter. Rila Fukushima has appeared in TV’s Arrow, The Wolverine and popped up in an episode of Game of Thrones, but she has not had the lead in any movie. Tao Okamoto starred in The Wolverine and popped up in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (utterly wasted there) as well as appearing in TV shows, Hannibal and The Man in The High Castle. Any one of them could have taken the role, if they had been considered or offered the chance. In all likelihood, the budget for the movie would have shrunk immensely as well.

Rinko, Rila, Tao

However, consider this. Japan has made live action adaptations of anime properties, complete with a Japanese cast in all the movies. Most of these movies have their fans, even on an international level. But how many have reached the average movie audience around the cinematic world? The most recent example would be the Attack on Titan duo logy (from a story aspect, doesn’t even take place in Japan) or even Parasyte. Before that, some may recall Death Note had two films made. THERMAE-ROMAE-THow about adaptations of more current anime properties such as Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae o Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai (aka AnoHana), Another, Ore Monogatari, or Assassination Classroom. It’s not to say the Japanese don’t have their own casting issues when they made an adaptation of Thermae Romae, where the lead character is supposed to be Roman. Twice.

Why am I not against the casting?

For one, the nature of the character Major Motoko Kusanagi is that she inhibits robotic bodies, the “Shell” in the title. Whatever her true physical flesh and blood body, it never appears in either the manga or the anime. The original anime ends with her robotic body being destroyed and she inhibits the body of a child robot at the end. gits_titlesBy the time Innocence (the animated sequel) rolled around, she is literally a ghost in the machine, momentarily inhibiting another robotic body near the end of the movie before disappearing into the ‘net again.

Simply by going with that, and not knowing what the plan is where the live action movie is concerned, why can’t the ’shell’ look like Scarlett Johansson? Also, the setting of the original story is in a near future, so why can’t racial or ethnic diversity be accepted?

Oh, right, there was that Aloha debacle where Emma Stone’s character was supposed to be Chinese. That’s despite logical reasoning behind her character’s ethnicity (1/4 Chinese, 1/4 Hawaiian, 1/2 AlohaScandinavian, giving her that blonde look) within the world of that movie. Heck, she could have been adopted into a Chinese family as a baby! It would have been entirely plausible.

Incidentally, no one seems to be making a fuss that they’ve cast Danish actor Pilou Asbæk as Batou. Or is that a little more acceptable because he’s less well-known? This isn’t quite like when several Chinese actresses were cast as the leads in Memoirs of a Geisha.

logoAs for Ghost in The Shell as a property. Let’s say you grab a hundred people around the world of various ages and a mix of sexes. Present that property and it’s likely generous to say 20 out of that hundred would know that property. They may be interested in checking out a live action adaptation of that property. Using that same hundred and present them with a futuristic sci-fi action movie starring Scarlett Johansson, and it’s safe to estimate up to 80 people would be interested in checking it out. Naturally, the studio will go for the bigger returns, perhaps alienate that small percentage while taking some lumps of protest.

I’m not alone in this as there are others of the same opinion.


Tilda SwintonADD: In some recent cases, Tilda Swinton got called out for playing “The Ancient One” in the upcoming Doctor Strange. In the comics, The Ancient One was a fairly ancient Asian looking man, so this has raised the ire of some people. It’s not like she hasn’t played an androgynous character before, and she’s on record stating that when she was offered the role of “The Ancient One”, it was never stated that it was supposed to be an Asian man.

However, somehow, the casting of Laurence Fishburne as Perry White in Man of Steel and Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, along with Mehcad Brooks as James Olsen in the Supergirl TV series, both characters being white in the comics for over 50 years, gets praised for colourblind casting.  On the other end of the spectrum (no pun intended), Zoe Saldana got slammed for taking on the role of Nina Simone because they needed to darken her skin for the role.

Noma DumezweniSome people took issue with the casting of coloured actress Noma Dumezweni as Hermione Granger in the stage production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. JK Rowling praised the casting by saying that she never once wrote that Hermoine had to be a white person. Often, it’s down to our personal sensibilities how we see these characters. As John Oliver put it, how is this still a thing?

To paraphrase a classic line, “Forget it, Jake. It’s Hollywood.”


Amazon (US) / Barnes and Noble / Amazon (Ca) / Amazon (UK) / Amazon (Jp) / Book Depository / Best Deals (


Amazon / Book Depository / ISBNS Net Barnes and Noble / aLibris Google Play Store


One thought on “Storm in a Teacup – Casting Fuss

  1. […] At the time of writing this, I’ve got ten minutes before the movie starts. I’ve been trying to manage expectations and I want to be clear about approaching this movie on its merits… but that’s a little difficult. I dropped by Rotten Tomatoes to not just get a general consensus among the top critics, but to get a sense of what others might have been expecting. Much of the fan community see to have generally negative reactions, with from the adaptation or the other controversy surrounding the movie. I’ve done my piece on that. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

April 2016
« Mar   May »



%d bloggers like this: